The BureauPlacePressCultureAll stories
Press
October 29, 2026

Brooklyn's neighborhood newsletters are printing paper issues

Newsletters were supposed to replace the neighborhood paper. Brooklyn's best are printing anyway, and starting to act like neighborhood institutions.

By Brouhaha Collective
Brooklyn's neighborhood newsletters are printing paper issues

Newsletters were supposed to be what came after the neighborhood paper. Instead, some of Brooklyn's best newsletters have started printing themselves. The Carroll Gardens Times, an email newsletter about one neighborhood, put out a paper Halloween issue this fall and left copies "at select locations around the neighborhood," as its Substack note put it.

The paper itself is almost beside the point. Writers who built an audience in the inbox are deciding the inbox isn't enough. They want to be on the coffee shop counter, at the screening, in the room. The best local newsletters are starting to behave less like newsletters and more like neighborhood institutions.

Gothamist noticed that almost all of Brooklyn's have "old-timey names": the Boerum Bulletin, the Court Street Journal. A name that sounds a century old is a claim to belong on the block, and readers showed up for it. Amber Jamieson started Bed-Stuy Stoop after a layoff and had 500 subscribers "in, like, a day." Vivien Kwok, who runs three of them, put the demand simply: since the pandemic, people "spend most of the time where they live."

Print gets a newsletter noticed. A subscription is private; a paper left on a counter gets found by people who never signed up, and a short run makes it something to keep and pass along. A few of the Halloween copies changed hands in a movie theater. Travis Hunter, the Carroll Gardens Times' editor, brought them to Emily Sundberg's final Monday Scaries screening at Cobble Hill Cinemas. Sundberg, who writes Feed Me, wrote that "introductions like that are exactly what I hoped would transpire from that screening series." The screening did something email can't: it put readers in the same room.

It isn't only Brooklyn. In Glasgow, 400 copies of The Bell's first print edition went in an hour at Central Station this fall, and one of its membership-drive pledges is at least three in-person events a year.

That's also why these newsletters matter to hotels. A concierge can tell a guest where to get coffee. A neighborhood writer can tell them why everyone suddenly cares about the bakery three blocks away, and what that block is talking about. Ace Hotel saw it early: it started its own Substack and published The Local's Guide to Brooklyn with the independent newsletter Perfectly Imperfect.

Stop treating neighborhood media as a smaller version of traditional media, somewhere to land a mention. These writers have a relationship with a few blocks that no city magazine can match, and that relationship is what makes them useful. Once a hotel sees them as neighbors, the opportunities get more interesting: put the paper at the front desk, host the next screening, give the writer a reason to know the place before you ever pitch them.

Brouhaha Collective is an earned media agency for travel, tourism and the brands around them.

Work with us →
More from the Bureau