The BureauPlacePressCultureAll stories
Place
November 4, 2026

The best restaurant reopenings change almost nothing

New owners of old restaurants are paying to keep the booths, murals and neon. The wear is the one thing a designer can't make, and the regulars already know the story.

By Brouhaha Collective
The best restaurant reopenings change almost nothing

The easy move with an old restaurant is to gut it and start fresh. This fall, the reopenings people are talking about go the other way: new owners are spending real money to make old rooms look the way they always did.

What they're buying is the one thing a designer can't make. When Toby Cecchini and Joel Tompkins opened the Long Island Bar in Brooklyn in 2013, they kept the 1950s room, and Cecchini told Grub Street that no designer could have built it because they "couldn't get the level of structural dilapidation." The wear is the asset. So are the people who remember the place, who turn up to the reopening already knowing the story. Here are the revivals keeping the right things.

Café des Artistes, New York

Ariel Arce had her high-school graduation lunch here before it closed in 2009. She and Max Katzenberg reopen it next year around the Howard Chandler Christy murals, which have been preserved. Her line on what it won't become: "we are not downtown kids coming uptown and making a small-plates restaurant, that's for sure."

The old Donohue's room, New York

Jon Neidich can't use the Donohue's Steak House name when he opens on Lexington Avenue in 2027, so the room has to do the remembering. The wood walls and black-and-white linoleum are being refurbished, black vinyl booths go back in, and the new bar stands where the old one did. "My goal is for it to feel very similar," he says.

Bar Ferdinando, Brooklyn

The owner of the century-old Ferdinando's Focacceria called much of it garbage and told Sal Lamboglia to toss whatever he liked. Lamboglia kept the look and the name on the sign. Asked whether keeping old things is cheaper, he said no: he redid the whole electrical system.

Cole's, Los Angeles

Cole's opened in 1908 to feed Red Car passengers and closed in March. New owners Jeremy Fall and Sean Maloney aim to reopen in mid-to-late November, pending the sale and a liquor license, and they are changing plenty: the pool tables go, white tablecloths and a piano come in. Mickey Cohen's booth and Bukowski's plaque stay, Time Out reports. New service around the old landmarks is a fair trade.

Formosa Cafe, West Hollywood

This revival worked by taking something away. The 1933 Group pulled off the drywall that hid the Formosa's original Pacific Electric trolley car and restored it down to the gold "913" lettering. The two-year job cost upwards of $2 million, according to the Los Angeles Conservancy, which gave it a preservation award in 2020.

Mickey's Diner, St. Paul

When the 1939 diner reopened in 2024 after more than four years dark, its manager, Sam Hashish, added espresso and vegetarian dishes and put them somewhere else. "The new stuff that we're adding is going to be on a separate menu," he told MPR News. "We're keeping the old-school menu Mickey's, still the same."

The Tony Hotel, Miami Beach

The hotel is named for the preservationist Tony Goldman, but the neon tower above it still reads Tiffany, its 1939 name, because the Miami Design Preservation League insisted. The other renovated hotels along that stretch, from the Delano to the Shelborne, kept their signs too, Monocle reports, and the Shelborne's neon was tweaked only to meet rules protecting hatching sea turtles. "Once historic context is lost, it cannot be recreated," says the league's Meg Lousteau.

Why the real room wins

The clearest proof comes from a place that had no old room to keep. Good Time Country Buffet in the East Village recreates the Atlanta-area buffets its owners grew up with, down to a bulletin board of fake community notices, and in its first month lines formed up First Avenue before the 5 p.m. opening. If a memory built from props can draw a queue, a room with the real one deserves better than a gut renovation.

Treat the old room as the story itself. A sign, a booth or a mural gives a reopening something the neighborhood already cares about, and gives a reporter something to write about before a single plate goes out. Call the regulars before you call the press. They're the ones who'll tell it.

Brouhaha Collective is an earned media agency for travel, tourism and the brands around them.

Work with us →
More from the Bureau